Climate Risk to Old-Age Income: Beyond Pension Funds
In 2025, typhoons and other natural disasters displaced an estimated 10.7 million people within the Philippines. None of them would have been helped by a pension fund cutting down its exposure in oil or mining stocks.
When climate change and old age income security are studied together, research tends to centre on one aspect – whether fund managers of large pension funds are holding too many shares in fossil fuel companies, whether they have properly priced climate risk and whether pension fund trustees are doing their duties. While important, this hardly touches the life of the average person growing old in most parts of the world.
The people most vulnerable to climate change typically live in poorer countries, where pension systems hold few assets. A paper by Barry Murphy, a researcher, drawing on the WageIndicator Global Pensions and Old-Age Income Security Database (forthcoming, February 2027), argues that climate change impacts old-age income security in such countries mainly through the parts of the pension system nobody studies.
The old age systems in poorer countries tend to rely on tax-funded social pensions, and informal and non-financial support from land, livestock and family. These make up, respectively, Pillar 0 and Pillar 4 of the World Bank’s 5-pillar framework for studying pension systems.
Pillar 1 comprises mandatory public schemes, typically for formal employees.
Pillar 2 refers to mandatory individual savings, usually compulsory personal retirement accounts funded by contributions.
Pillar 3 is voluntary savings.
Together, these are called contributory pensions and such schemes typically don’t reach the informal workforce – which makes up about 90.2% for low income countries, and 83.4% for lower middle income nations, according to data from the International Labour Organisation. The informal workforce’s vulnerability to climate change is felt through public budgets, the loss of informal support, and when they are forced to move.
How climate reaches the old: three routes
The first channel of climate change impact on pensions is government finances. Social pension is funded through tax receipts and in low-income countries that revenue is fragile. A drought or a flood can hurt government revenues and force emergency spending at the same time, squeezing the budget line that funds social pensions. Climate events also add to the scale and frequency of shocks, landing on the youngest and least entrenched social pensions.
While social pensions are rarely abolished, they can very well stall. For instance, Kenya’s Inua Jamii has been frozen at Kenyan Shilling 2,000 since the late 2010s and has lost about a third of its real value. Kenya has high public debt and in 2024–25, it had to delay pension payments to many beneficiaries because of budget shortfalls. This reveals a fragility that climate change could exploit.
To be sure, this is not always the case. Fiji, for example, delivered emergency top-ups to its social-pension recipients after Tropical Cyclone Winston and again during COVID-19 despite budgetary pressures. In effect, it is a matter of political priorities and not just budget maths.
“ Whether climate shocks mean a future erosion of non-contributory pensions is a critical issue looking forward. We raise it as one of the central questions the database could help track over time. ”
Barry Murphy, researcher
The second channel how climate change hits old age security is by eroding the informal base. For most of the world’s elderly, Pillar 4 is the real pension, the paper argues. Floods and droughts destroy land, livestock and housing. Take for example the 2022 floods in Pakistan, the worst in recorded history, that displaced an estimated 8 million people. Repeated floods since have produced large-scale, longer-duration displacement and protracted recovery, with many 2022-flood families still not fully recovered years later, the paper said.
The third route through which climate change hits the aged is when they are forced to move. Pension rights are tied to places and systems, and climate is pushing people to move. When people cross borders, they can keep their accrued rights only when an agreement exists between their home country and where they end up. The paper points out such agreements are rare and tend to exist mainly along well-established labour migration routes rather than climate displacement routes.
What three countries show about pensions and displacement
The paper illustrates the challenge by taking a sample of the old age systems in three countries – Kenya, Philippines and Pakistan to show that when climate forces people to move, what protects them is how well the system is synced with the way they actually move. Kenya, for example, has no agreements with any country. Pakistan has no agreements with the gulf nations which host most of its outbound workers. While the Philippines has 16 agreements, none cover Hong Kong or the Gulf states, where most of its overseas workers go. The burden falls mostly on women care workers.
The paper also suggests that most climate displacement is internal and the question of how pension benefits port within a country deserves more attention. Based on the study of these three countries, it makes a few suggestions, each aimed at mitigating the stress from climate change from one of the three routes:
Index social pensions to inflation: As Kenya’s case clearly shows, when budgets are squeezed the real value of pension payments can go down in the absence of indexation.
Build and extend state pension: Contributory schemes can’t reach the informal majority and thus the state has to bear the burden when informal support is destroyed by climate events.
Line up cross-border agreements with the routes people actually travel.
Make benefits portable within the country, not just across borders.
In sum, how old age income security systems respond to climate change lies less in the holdings of pension funds than on whether social pensions keep their value, informal support survives, and benefits follow people when they move.
Read more @wageindicator
