How pension risk transfer works and why companies are buying annuities
Pension risk transfer is the purchase of group annuities from an insurer to cover a company’s defined benefit pension obligations. In a buy-out, the insurer takes over paying the pensions and the liability leaves the plan; in a buy-in, the plan buys an annuity contract as an investment that matches its payments, and the obligation stays with the plan. US companies bought $31.3 billion of buy-outs and $17.5 billion of buy-ins in 2025, according to LIMRA, a combined $48.8 billion.
The mix shifted sharply last year. LIMRA said buy-out sales fell 35% from 2024 across 683 contracts, while buy-in sales rose 372% across 17 contracts. Fourth-quarter sales reached $28 billion, up 132% from a year earlier, including a record $12.7 billion of buy-ins. Total single-premium pension risk transfer assets held by insurers stood at $342.1 billion at the end of 2025.
Activity then slowed. LIMRA reported on 1 July 2026 that first-quarter buy-out and buy-in sales totaled about $3.8 billion, down 47% from a year earlier, across 102 contracts. It attributed most of the drop to deals pulled into the end of 2025 and said some advisers were urging sponsors with better funded plans to delay. “Evolving market perspectives may be influencing timing decisions,” said Keith Golembiewski, head of LIMRA annuity research.
Cost is one reason companies transfer pensions. Single-employer plans pay the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation a flat-rate premium of $111 per participant for 2026, rising to $116 in 2027, plus a variable-rate premium of $52 for every $1,000 of unfunded vested benefits, capped at $751 per participant in 2026 and $783 in 2027. PBGC says the flat rate and the cap remain indexed, while the variable rate has not been indexed since 2024. Each retiree moved to an insurer through a buy-out removes a head from that premium bill, along with the administration and investment risk.
Choosing the insurer is a fiduciary decision under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act. The Labor Department’s Interpretive Bulletin 95-1 says fiduciaries must take steps calculated to obtain the safest annuity available, unless it would be in the interests of participants and beneficiaries to do otherwise, and must run an objective, thorough and analytical search. Relying only on ratings from insurance rating services is not enough.
The bulletin lists six factors to weigh: the quality and diversification of the insurer’s investment portfolio, the size of the insurer relative to the contract, its capital and surplus, its lines of business and other exposures, the structure of the contract and any separate accounts backing it, and the protection available from state guaranty associations. Fiduciaries without the expertise to judge those factors need a qualified, independent adviser. Cost can justify a choice other than the very safest annuity only in limited cases, and never in a way that puts benefits at risk.
Congress asked the Labor Department to review the bulletin in the SECURE 2.0 Act of 2022. In its report to Congress on 24 June 2024, the department said it was not prepared to change the bulletin, according to the law firm Groom, and that any future changes would go through public notice and comment. Groom said the ERISA Advisory Council had split, with six members opposed to changes and nine favoring various changes without agreeing on any.
Litigation is the newer risk. Retirees have sued companies including Lockheed Martin, AT&T, Alcoa, General Electric and Bristol-Myers Squibb over transfers to the insurer Athene, and district courts have split on whether retirees whose pensions are still being paid have standing to sue, according to Nixon Peabody. Courts in Maryland and New York let claims against Lockheed Martin and Bristol-Myers Squibb proceed, and both rulings are on appeal; a Pennsylvania court dismissed a case against ATI on 27 July 2026, calling it “a close call.” On 21 July 2026 the Labor Department filed an amicus brief in the Second Circuit in Doherty v. Bristol-Myers Squibb, supporting the company and arguing that the plaintiffs lacked standing under the Supreme Court’s decisions in Thole and Clapper.
In Britain, the alternative to an insurance deal is becoming more practical. The Pension Schemes Act 2026, which received Royal Assent on 29 April 2026, gives defined benefit schemes more flexibility to release surplus funds, which the government said could unlock around £160 billion for employers and members. The details, including the funding level a scheme must reach before surplus can be paid out, depend on regulations that have yet to be made.
A sponsor weighing a transfer compares the premium an insurer quotes with the full cost of keeping the plan, including PBGC premiums, administration and investment risk, and then has to document an insurer selection that meets the Labor Department’s safest-annuity standard.
Read more @ceoeconomy
